Esthetically pleasing matches my black and white motifTwo things which may be of concern:1. The cheap thin nylon backing around the book holder2. The wood cut curve design to grab the rim of the tub is not a good match for all tubs. I have a freestanding which has beveled sides and a deeper and higher back than front. This creates a slanted sleek design. Unfortunately the curves on this tray do not grip well, there is not added rubber or silicone grip on the bottom, so it falls in the tub… often.1. Add your own rubberized gripper tape to the bottom or2. Don’t put a glass of wine and a good book on the tray… they’re apt to go swimming?The bath caddy is wonderful. It was a Christmas gift and came in a box marked very clearly on the outside, ruining the surprise for my daughter. Other than that, I don’t have any complaints.Wood is very nice but a little loose slides too easyI really liked this over the tub tray. It’s convenient, easy to use, already assembled, has a cup holder, a book/iPad/phone holder, and it stretched wide enough for the tub we have which is a little wider than your standard tub. The reason I didn’t give it 5 stars, is because it doesn’t have the mechanism, that I’m aware of, to lock the tray in place so that it doesn’t get smaller if you push it on accident. Just be careful if you have a wide tub, because if the sides slide in, it will fall into the tub with whatever is on it.This was a game changer for my bathroom. I now relax in the tub 2 to 3 days a week. It's sturdy but the color faded on the corners due to my bubbling water hitting it for 30 minutes. Unnoticeable. It's still nice and I recommend this productWe have a very wide spa bath tub so have to pull it out almost to the end. It then becomes week in the middle when you put anything of weight on it.I loved the quality. A bit bulky for today’s tubsThis thing is awesome. I use it every day. I dropped my tablet and my phone onto the bath twice but since I got this it hasn't happened once. I have a garden/soaking tub and the tray fully stretches with room to spare. Also, my 17 pound giant cat likes to stand on it and it doesn't even flex from her weight. Love this!This is not built properly. There is nothing to stop from sliding off sides of tub. We had to add some wood underneath to ensure no accidents. The manufacturer needs to revisit this build Not worth the priceGood quality, looks great. Just as described.Très bienSuper